Featured Haunt

Hotel · You can stay here

The Pfister Hotel, Milwaukee: The Hotel That Spooks Major League Baseball

424 E Wisconsin Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53202

The Pfister is a Victorian grand hotel in downtown Milwaukee, opened in 1893, where visiting Major League Baseball teams stay. Its ghost stories are unusually well attested: several players have described their own experiences to the press, including Bryce Harper, who told ESPN he woke to find his clothes on the floor and a table moved with his door still latched. Others have refused to stay. The ghost of founder Charles Pfister on the grand staircase, the hotel's best-known legend, has no named witness, and the hotel won't comment on ghosts.

The Pfister Hotel
Michael Barera (CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons) · License

The Pfister Hotel at a glance

Can you stay here?
Yes: rooms can be bookedType: Hotel
Ghosts reported
The ballplayers' nights, Charles Pfister
Most haunted spots
Rooms in the 1893 building (ask when booking)
Built
1890-93 for Guido and Charles Pfister, designed by Henry C. Koch; tower added 1965
Verification
Featured HauntWhat this means

Is the Pfister Hotel haunted?

The building's history is well documented by the Wisconsin Historical Society and the National Register nomination for its historic district.

The ghost evidence is unusual for having so many named, first-hand witnesses. In ESPN The Magazine in 2013, Bryce Harper, Brandon Phillips, Michael Young and Pablo Sandoval each described something they couldn't explain, while Shane Victorino said nothing is wrong with the hotel. Others, like Carlos Gómez, told the Associated Press it scared them. These are self-reported, and players are known to prank each other; one local paranormal investigator suggests exactly that. The ghost of Charles Pfister has no named witness.

What we checked:Documented history × 5Published account × 5Legend × 1Disputed × 1See each claim

The ghosts of the Pfister Hotel

The ballplayers' nights

Reported

Seen: Guest rooms

Moved furniture, radios and iPods turning on, footsteps in locked rooms. Described first-hand by named players.

Charles Pfister

Legend

Seen: Grand staircase and ballroom gallery

The man who finished the hotel, said to watch over it. No named witness.

Ghost stories and sightings

The ballplayers

Visiting baseball teams have stayed at the Pfister for decades, and many players have described strange nights. In 2013 Bryce Harper told ESPN The Magazine he woke to find his clothes on the floor and a table moved across the room, with his door still latched; he suspected teammates, who denied it, and moved to a higher floor. Brandon Phillips said a radio turned itself back on while he showered, Michael Young heard footsteps in his locked room, and Pablo Sandoval found his iPod playing. Sandoval and Edgar Renteria paid to stay elsewhere in 2010.

Scared away

Carlos Gómez told the Associated Press in 2009 that he ran to the lobby after his iPod changed songs by itself. Justin Upton said he'd pay for another hotel next time, and Mookie Betts stayed in an Airbnb. Adrian Beltre's 2001 account of knocking in his room, and sleeping with a bat, is widely retold, though we couldn't find the original.

The skeptics

Shane Victorino told ESPN: "it's not haunted. There's nothing wrong with that hotel." C.J. Wilson pointed out that players play key-card pranks on each other, and a Milwaukee paranormal investigator says the same.

Charles Pfister

A portly, smiling gentleman said to be Charles Pfister, who finished the hotel, is said to appear on the grand staircase and in the gallery above the ballroom. No witness is named. The hotel won't comment on ghosts, saying the only thing haunting it is "the spirit of hospitality."

A burying ground?

A rumor says the hotel stands on a graveyard. It traces to an 1893 newspaper interview in which a man recalled a private burying ground on the site, but said he found no bones when the ground was broken.

History of the Pfister Hotel

The Pfisters' hotel

Guido Pfister, a leather merchant, and his son Charles commissioned the hotel from architect Henry C. Koch. Guido died before it was finished; Charles completed it and it opened in 1893, built in Wauwatosa limestone and cream brick. The National Register nomination for its district calls it the last 19th-century grand hotel left in downtown Milwaukee. Charles Pfister died in 1927.

The Marcus years

Ben Marcus bought the hotel at auction in 1962, and the Marcus family company still owns and runs it. A 23-story tower was added in 1965. The hotel is a contributing building in the East Side Commercial Historic District, listed on the National Register in 1986.

Today

The Pfister has a large collection of Victorian art, and a $20 million renovation of its ballrooms, rooms and lobby was completed in 2025.

Timeline

  1. 1893

    The Pfister opens

  2. 1962

    Bought by Ben Marcus

  3. 1965

    The tower is added

  4. September 23, 1986

    National Register district listed

  5. 2012

    Bryce Harper's night

  6. November 20, 2025

    Renovation completed

The evidence, claim by claim

What each story about the Pfister Hotel rests on. A published account shows that someone reported an experience, not what caused it.

The Pfister opened, designed by Henry C. Koch for Guido and Charles Pfister.

Guido died before it opened.

[1], [2]

Documented history

Ben Marcus bought the hotel at auction; his family company still owns it.

[3]

Documented history

A 23-story tower was added.

Other sources say 1962 or 1964.

[1]

Documented history

The hotel is part of the East Side Commercial Historic District on the National Register.

Not listed individually.

[2]

Documented history

Adrian Beltre heard knocking in his room and slept with a bat.

The original article couldn't be found.

[4]

Published account

Carlos Gómez ran to the lobby after his iPod changed songs by itself.

[5]

Published account

Pablo Sandoval and Edgar Renteria paid to stay at another hotel.

Confirmed by the team.

[6], [7]

Published account

Bryce Harper woke to find his clothes on the floor and a table moved, with his door latched.

Self-reported; he suspected teammates.

[7]

Published account

Players have pranked each other at the hotel, and a local investigator suspects pranks.

[8], [7]

Published account

Charles Pfister's ghost is seen on the grand staircase.

No named witness; the hotel doesn't comment.

[9]

Legend

The hotel stands on a burying ground.

One 1893 recollection; no bones were found.

[9]

Disputed

A $20 million renovation was completed.

[10]

Documented history

Tips for staying at the Pfister Hotel

  • See the lobby and art collection without staying; the hotel offers art tours, and the lobby bar is open to the public.
  • Ask for a room in the 1893 building rather than the 1965 tower if you want the historic part.
  • There's no haunted-room package or ghost tour; the hotel doesn't market its ghosts.

The Pfister Hotel: FAQs

Which rooms at the Pfister Hotel are haunted?

The most reported areas are: Rooms in the 1893 building (ask when booking).

Is the Pfister Hotel haunted?

Several Major League Baseball players have described unexplained experiences there on the record, including Bryce Harper. Others say it's pranks. The hotel doesn't comment on ghosts.

What did Bryce Harper say about the Pfister?

He told ESPN The Magazine in 2013 that he woke to find his clothes on the floor and a table moved across the room, with his door still latched, and asked to move rooms.

Do baseball players refuse to stay at the Pfister?

Some have chosen other hotels, including Pablo Sandoval in 2010 and Mookie Betts in 2023, but most visiting teams still stay there.

Is the Pfister built on a graveyard?

The rumor comes from an 1893 recollection of a private burying ground on the site, but the man who told it said he found no bones.

Guest experiences (0)

Share your experience →

No guest accounts yet. If you've stayed here, yours could be the first.

Share your experience

Sources

  1. Property Record: 424 E Wisconsin Ave (Hotel Pfister), Wisconsin Historical Society Build dates, the 1965 tower and register dates.Checked November 14, 2026
  2. Vollmert, Wenger and Hatala, East Side Commercial Historic District: National Register nomination, National Park Service, September 23, 1986 Henry C. Koch; "the last nineteenth century grand hotel" downtown.Checked November 14, 2026
  3. About, The Pfister Hotel Checked November 14, 2026
  4. Mookie Betts opts to stay at an Airbnb to avoid Milwaukee hotel with haunted history, Fox Sports, May 10, 2023 Also retells Beltre's 2001 account.Checked November 14, 2026
  5. 'Haunted' Milwaukee Hotel Spooks Baseball Teams, Associated Press (via Fox News), July 11, 2009 Carlos Gómez; the general manager on guest privacy.Checked November 14, 2026
  6. Jay Barmann, Two Giants players switch hotels, SFist, July 6, 2010 Sandoval and Renteria, with team confirmation.Checked November 14, 2026
  7. Stacey Pressman, The haunting of MLB's A-List, ESPN The Magazine, May 31, 2013 First-person accounts from Harper, Phillips, Young, Sandoval and others, and skeptics.Checked November 14, 2026
  8. Lance Schulteis, Stunts, spirits or secrets? A local investigator weighs in on the legend of the Pfister Hotel, Marquette Wire, October 28, 2025 A skeptical view.Checked November 14, 2026
  9. Becky Mortensen, The legend of the Pfister Hotel ghost, WUWM, October 31, 2022 The 1893 burying-ground article and the hotel's no-comment stance.Checked November 14, 2026
  10. The Pfister Hotel Completes Multi-Phase Renovation, Marcus Hotels & Resorts, November 20, 2025 Checked November 14, 2026

Page last reviewed November 21, 2026.