Unverified

Hotel · You can stay here

The Strater Hotel, Durango: The Railroad Engineer and a Skeptical Owner

699 Main Ave, Durango, CO 81301

The Strater Hotel opened on Durango's Main Avenue in 1887, built by Cleveland pharmacist Henry Strater, and is still open, with its Diamond Belle Saloon and Room 222, where Louis L'Amour wrote. Locals and guests tell of a woman at an upper window, a man dressed as a railroad engineer crossing the lobby and a little girl, but no witness is named. Its longtime owner, Rod Barker, told the Durango Herald in 2019 that he'd seen "no evidence whatsoever" of ghosts. The hotel doesn't market a haunted room.

The Strater Hotel
Ken Lund (CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons) · License

The Strater Hotel at a glance

Can you stay here?
Yes: rooms can be bookedType: Hotel
Ghosts reported
The railroad engineer, the woman at the window, the little girl
Most haunted spots
No particular room; reports place sightings on the upper floors
Built
1887 for pharmacist Henry Strater and his family
Verification
UnverifiedWhat this means

Is the Strater Hotel haunted?

The hotel's history is well documented by the hotel, Historic Hotels of America and the National Register, which listed it as part of Durango's Main Avenue Historic District in 1980.

The ghost material is thin. The sightings come from unnamed locals and guests, retold in a 2016 magazine piece and in Nancy Williams's 2019 book Haunted Hotels of Southern Colorado, which the Durango Herald says relies mostly on secondhand reports. The owner, Rod Barker, says the only credible stories are "things that go bump in the night," usually ice machines. Some sources also mix up the Strater with the Rochester Hotel, whose Room 204 is Durango's best-known haunted room.

What we checked:Documented history × 8Published account × 2Disputed × 1Unverified × 1See each claim

The ghosts of the Strater Hotel

The railroad engineer

Reported

Seen: Lobby

A man in period railroad dress crossing the lobby. Reported by unnamed guests.

The woman at the window

Legend

Seen: Upper floor, facing Main Avenue

Seen by locals looking down on the street. No witness named.

The little girl

Legend

Seen: Halls

A child running about. No name or story behind her.

Ghost stories and sightings

The engineer, the girl and the woman at the window

The Strater stands by the old railroad, and its best-known ghost is a man dressed as a railroad engineer, reported walking through the lobby. Guests also describe a little girl running about, and some locals say they've seen a woman sitting at an upper window looking down on Main Avenue. A 2016 DGO Magazine piece adds a man in a white shirt on the tracks in the alley, and says the rooms kept "ghost diaries" where guests wrote down sightings, most on the upper floors. None of these witnesses is named.

The owner says no

In her 2019 book Haunted Hotels of Southern Colorado, Nancy Williams quoted owner Rod Barker as telling the Herald in 1999 that the hotel had "uninvited visitors" who terrified and thrilled guests. Barker told the Durango Herald in 2019 that he would never have said that. "I have seen no evidence whatsoever of ghosts in the Strater," he said. "The only stories that sound somewhat credible are things that go bump in the night, and those can usually be explained by ice machines and such." He added: "We like to keep our spirits in the Diamond Belle, because that's a good place for them."

Not the Strater

A woman in Victorian clothing in Room 204, the "John Wayne Room," belongs to the Rochester Hotel a few blocks away, not the Strater.

History of the Strater Hotel

Henry Strater's hotel

Henry Strater, a young pharmacist from Cleveland, built the hotel with his father and brothers for $70,000, using 376,000 red bricks and carved sandstone trim, and opened it in 1887. Townsfolk moved in for the winter, when their own homes were too cold. Strater kept his pharmacy on the corner and leased the hotel to H.L. Rice, but forgot to exclude the pharmacy from the lease; in 1893 he built the rival Columbian Hotel next door. The silver panic ruined them both by 1895, and the Bank of Cleveland sold the Strater to Hattie Mashburn and Charles E. Stilwell.

The Barker years

In 1926 a group led by banker Earl A. Barker Sr. bought the hotel, and the Barker family ran it for most of the next century. Earl Barker Jr. turned a corner shop back to a saloon, the Diamond Belle, in 1957, and with his wife Jentra began the collection of Victorian walnut furniture. Louis L'Amour always asked for Room 222, above the saloon, and wrote much of his Sackett series there. The hotel became part of the Main Avenue Historic District on the National Register in 1980 and a charter member of Historic Hotels of America in 1989.

Today

In May 2021 the Barkers sold the hotel to Ross Garrett and Karen Hutcherson. It has 88 rooms, the Diamond Belle, the Office Spiritorium and the Mahogany Grille.

Timeline

  1. 1887

    The Strater opens

  2. 1893

    The Columbian Hotel

  3. 1926

    The Barkers buy it

  4. 1957

    The Diamond Belle

  5. August 7, 1980

    National Register listing

  6. May 2021

    New owners

The evidence, claim by claim

What each story about the Strater Hotel rests on. A published account shows that someone reported an experience, not what caused it.

Henry Strater and his family opened the hotel, built for $70,000.

[1], [2]

Documented history

Strater built the rival Columbian Hotel next door after a dispute over the lease.

[3], [2]

Documented history

The silver panic ruined both hotels, and the bank sold the Strater to Hattie Mashburn and Charles E. Stilwell.

[1], [2]

Documented history

A group led by Earl A. Barker Sr. bought the hotel.

[1], [2]

Documented history

Earl Barker Jr. restored the Diamond Belle Saloon.

[4], [3]

Documented history

Louis L'Amour wrote much of his Sackett series in Room 222.

Sources differ on when his stays began.

[1], [4], [2]

Documented history

The hotel was listed on the National Register as part of the Main Avenue Historic District.

[5], [6]

Documented history

Guests report a man dressed as a railroad engineer in the lobby, and locals a woman at an upper window.

No witness named.

[7], [8]

Published account

The rooms kept "ghost diaries" of guests' sightings.

One 2016 magazine report; the hotel doesn't mention them.

[7]

Unverified

Owner Rod Barker told the Herald in 1999 that the hotel had "uninvited visitors."

Quoted in a 2019 book; Barker says he never would have said it.

[8] (disagrees)

Disputed

Rod Barker said he had seen no evidence whatsoever of ghosts at the hotel.

[8]

Published account

The Barkers sold the hotel to Ross Garrett and Karen Hutcherson.

[1], [2]

Documented history

Tips for staying at the Strater Hotel

  • Ask for Room 222, the Louis L'Amour room, by phone on (800) 247-4431; the hotel doesn't market a haunted room.
  • The Diamond Belle Saloon has costumed staff and ragtime piano, and the lobby showcases are open to visitors.
  • The Durango & Silverton Narrow Gauge Railroad depot is a short walk down Main Avenue.

The Strater Hotel: FAQs

Which rooms at the Strater Hotel are haunted?

The most reported areas are: No particular room; reports place sightings on the upper floors.

Is the Strater Hotel haunted?

Locals and guests tell of a railroad engineer in the lobby, a little girl and a woman at an upper window, but no witness is named. Its longtime owner, Rod Barker, says he's seen no evidence of ghosts.

Is Room 222 at the Strater haunted?

No ghost is linked to it. Room 222 is the Louis L'Amour room, where the author wrote his Sackett novels above the Diamond Belle Saloon.

Is Room 204 in Durango haunted?

The haunted Room 204, the John Wayne Room, is at the Rochester Hotel, not the Strater.

Can you visit the Strater without staying?

Yes. The hotel invites visitors to walk through the lobby and its showcases, and the Diamond Belle Saloon is open to all.

Guest experiences (0)

Share your experience →

No guest accounts yet. If you've stayed here, yours could be the first.

Share your experience

Sources

  1. History of The Strater Hotel, Historic Hotels of America Checked November 20, 2026
  2. A Living History Museum, The Strater Hotel The hotel's history; no ghost content.Checked November 20, 2026
  3. The Strater Story, The Strater Hotel, 2023 The Diamond Belle in 1957.Checked November 20, 2026
  4. The Strater Hotel, Historic Hotels of America Member since 1989; L'Amour's rooms.Checked November 20, 2026
  5. Strater Hotel, Wikipedia Checked November 20, 2026
  6. Main Avenue Historic District (NRIS 80000907), National Park Service, August 7, 1980 Checked November 20, 2026
  7. Durango's most haunted places, DGO Magazine, October 26, 2016 Unnamed sightings and the "ghost diaries."Checked November 20, 2026
  8. Ann Butler, Seen by some and not others, ghosts said to haunt area hotels, Durango Herald, October 30, 2019 Quotes owner Rod Barker; describes Nancy Williams's book.Checked November 20, 2026

Page last reviewed November 20, 2026.

Brave enough to stay at the Strater Hotel?

Check room prices and availability for your dates.

Check prices & availabilityon Booking.com

More haunted hotels in Colorado

All haunted hotels in Colorado →
Hotel Colorado
Verified Haunt

Hotel Colorado

Glenwood Springs

An 1893 Italianate resort hotel beside Glenwood Hot Springs, where Teddy Roosevelt stayed and the Navy ran a wartime hospital. Its ghost stories come from staff and a 1995 book.

Check prices
The Oxford Hotel
Unverified

The Oxford Hotel

Denver

One of Denver's oldest hotels, opened in 1891 a block from Union Station. Its Room 320 'murder room' and Cruise Room postman are told by the hotel itself, but no record backs either story.

Check prices
Hotel Boulderado
Verified Haunt

Hotel Boulderado

Boulder

Boulder's first grand hotel, opened on New Year's Day 1909. A longtime manager has described odd events in Suites 302 and 304 on the record, but the double suicide said to lie behind them has no record.

Check prices