Footsteps and whispers
LegendSeen: Rooms 21 and 22
Footsteps, cold breezes, smells and whispers, reported by unnamed guests and staff.
Hotel · You can stay here
6387 Mill St, Rhinebeck, NY 12572
The Beekman Arms stands at the crossroads of Rhinebeck, New York, in the Hudson Valley, and is open, with the Delamater Inn a short walk away. The building was begun in 1766, and Franklin D. Roosevelt ended his campaigns from its porch. Historic Hotels of America says guests and staff report footsteps, cold breezes and whispers "especially in Rooms 21 and 22," and that employees tell of a dark figure that comes out of the wine cellar. No witness is named, and the inn's "oldest" title is its own claim.

The inn's history is reasonably well documented: it stands in the Rhinebeck Village Historic District, listed on the National Register in 1979, and its owners can be traced from the Traphagens and Bogarduses through Tracy Dows, who remodeled it in 1918. The 1704 founding date comes from the inn's own history.
The ghost material is thin. It comes almost entirely from Historic Hotels of America's 2025 most-haunted list, which reports unnamed guests' and staff's experiences, and from ghost-story evenings and paranormal group visits. We found no named witness, newspaper account or record behind any of it.
What we checked:Documented history × 9Disputed × 1Unverified × 5See each claim
Seen: Rooms 21 and 22
Footsteps, cold breezes, smells and whispers, reported by unnamed guests and staff.
Seen: Wine cellar and kitchen
A black figure said by employees to come out of the wine cellar. No witness named.
Historic Hotels of America, which put the inn on its 2025 list of most haunted hotels, says: "Guests and staff alike report ghostly footsteps, cold breezes, strange smells, and whispers, especially in Rooms 21 and 22." It names none of them.
The same list calls the Tavern, the oldest part of the inn, the place where strange sightings most often happen. "The most consistent story told by employees is the sighting of a black figure that emerges from the wine cellar," it says, and the figure "has also been seen walking around the kitchen." Visitors and staff have photographed orbs in the Tavern's dining room and attic.
Staff consider the basement the most haunted part of the inn, and it carries stories that tie it to the Underground Railroad and Prohibition. We found no record of the Underground Railroad claim. The inn has held autumn ghost-story evenings down there, with tours every Friday night through November 2019, and in March 2019 a paranormal group called the Ghost Magnets held an investigation at the inn.
We haven’t confirmed this with the hotel yet.
Named by Historic Hotels of America for footsteps and whispers. Ask by phone.
Ask when you book: nothing is guaranteed until the hotel agrees.
We haven’t confirmed this with the hotel yet.
Named by Historic Hotels of America for footsteps and whispers. Ask by phone.
Ask when you book: nothing is guaranteed until the hotel agrees.
The inn's own history says William Traphagen opened a tavern at the Rhinebeck crossroads in 1704. The present building was begun in 1766, under his grandson Arent Traphagen. Everardus Bogardus bought it around 1769, and as the Bogardus Tavern it served the Revolutionary era; Historic Hotels of America says Continental troops drilled on its lawn and that George Washington, Alexander Hamilton and Benedict Arnold all stayed there, which we haven't checked against their papers. Later owners renamed it Potter's and then Jacques' Tavern.
Tracy Dows remodeled the inn in 1918 and added a ballroom. Franklin D. Roosevelt, who lived at nearby Hyde Park, ended each of his campaigns for governor and president with a speech from its front porch. Charles LaForge Jr. bought it in 1958, and in 1979 the Henry Delamater House, a Gothic Revival home of 1844 designed by Alexander Jackson Davis, became the Delamater Inn. George Banta Sr. bought both in 2002. The inn has about 80 rooms across its buildings and joined Historic Hotels of America in 2006.
1704
Traphagen's tavern
1766
The inn is built
1769
The Bogardus Tavern
1844
The Delamater House
1918
Dows remodels the inn
August 8, 1979
National Register listing
What each story about Beekman Arms and Delamater Inn rests on. A published account shows that someone reported an experience, not what caused it.
William Traphagen opened a tavern at the Rhinebeck crossroads.
From the inn's own history; not the present building.
George Washington, Alexander Hamilton and Benedict Arnold stayed at the inn.
Told by Historic Hotels of America; not checked against their papers.
Tracy Dows remodeled the inn and added a ballroom.
The inn became part of a historic district listed on the National Register.
The Beekman Arms is America's oldest continuously operating inn.
The inn's own claim; it dates itself to 1766, while Historic Hotels of America uses 1704.
Guests and staff report footsteps, cold breezes, smells and whispers in Rooms 21 and 22.
No witness named.
Employees report a black figure that comes out of the wine cellar and walks in the kitchen.
No witness named.
The inn held basement ghost-story tours every Friday night.
The inn was named one of Historic Hotels of America's most haunted hotels.
Beekman Arms and Delamater Inn is said to be haunted by Footsteps and whispers and the dark figure.
We haven't confirmed it with the hotel yet. Ask when you book: nothing is guaranteed until the hotel agrees.
We haven't confirmed it with the hotel yet. Ask when you book: nothing is guaranteed until the hotel agrees.
The most reported areas are: Rooms 21 and 22, the Tavern and the basement.
Historic Hotels of America says guests and staff report footsteps, whispers and cold breezes, especially in Rooms 21 and 22, and a dark figure from the wine cellar. No witness is named, so the stories are hard to check.
Rooms 21 and 22, according to Historic Hotels of America. Staff also point to the Tavern, the kitchen and the basement.
It's the inn's own claim. The building dates from 1766; the 1704 date belongs to an earlier tavern founded by William Traphagen.
Franklin D. Roosevelt, who lived at Hyde Park nearby, ended each of his campaigns for governor and president with a speech from its front porch.
No guest accounts yet. If you've stayed here, yours could be the first.
Share your experiencePage last reviewed November 20, 2026.
Check room prices and availability for your dates.

A sandstone castle on Seneca Lake, built in 1885-89, later a speakeasy and casino and now a hotel and winery. Its ghost, the opera singer Isabella, belongs to an older house on the site and has no record behind her.
Check pricesThe last of Saratoga Springs' 19th-century Broadway hotels, built in 1877 and reopened in 2017 after a long renovation. Boxer and casino founder John Morrissey died there in 1878; his ghost and a woman in a blue Victorian gown are local stories without named witnesses.
Check pricesNew York's 1884 home of writers, artists and musicians, reopened as a hotel in 2022. Residents tell of a weeping woman in the halls; her story has no record behind it.
Check prices