Unverified

Hotel · You can stay here

Belhurst Castle, Geneva: Isabella and the Seneca Lake Legend

4069 West Lake Rd, Geneva, NY 14456

Belhurst Castle is a sandstone mansion on Seneca Lake in Geneva, built in 1885-89 and run as a speakeasy and casino from 1933. Its best-known ghost is Isabella, an opera singer said to have fled Europe with a lover and died when their escape tunnel to the lake collapsed; she is said to stand on the lawn at night in white. The story belongs to an earlier house on the site, and no record of her has been found. You can stay in 11 rooms in the castle.

Belhurst Castle
RochesterNY (public domain, via Wikimedia Commons)

Belhurst Castle at a glance

Can you stay here?
Yes: rooms can be bookedType: Hotel
Ghosts reported
Isabella, Dick O'Brien, the casino room
Most haunted spots
No single room; the stories are set on the lawn, stairs, bar and old casino roomMore haunted rooms to ask for
Can you ask for Chambers in the Castle?
Yes, you can ask for it when you bookDetails
Built
1885-89 for Carrie M. Young Harron Collins, designed by Fuller & Wheeler; a speakeasy and casino from 1933; guest rooms since 1975
Verification
UnverifiedWhat this means

Is Belhurst Castle haunted?

The castle's history is well recorded: the hotel's own history, its 1987 National Register listing and local writers agree on its builders, its Prohibition casino and its owners since.

The ghost material is thin. Isabella is a legend tied to William Henry Bucke, who lived in an earlier house on the site in the 1830s; the hotel itself says only that the house was "rumored" to be haunted and that many believed in an escape tunnel. The stories of Isabella and of caretaker Dick O'Brien come from tourism pages and ghost guides, with no named witness.

What we checked:Documented history × 8Legend × 2Unverified × 3See each claim

The ghosts of Belhurst Castle

Isabella

Legend

Seen: Front lawn and lakeshore

An opera singer said to have died in a collapsing escape tunnel. No record of her.

Dick O'Brien

Legend

Seen: Main stairs and bar

A caretaker said to have died in 1972, blamed for pranks in the bar. No named witness.

The casino room

Reported

Seen: Former gambling room

Furniture heard moving overhead at night by unnamed guests.

Ghost stories and sightings

Isabella

The best-known ghost is Isabella, said to be an opera singer who fled Europe with a forbidden lover, called in some versions a "Spanish Don." The couple are said to have built a house on Seneca Lake with a secret tunnel to the shore, and when they were found, the tunnel collapsed on Isabella as they tried to escape to their boat. Guests describe a woman in white standing on the front lawn at night, or flying in through the windows. Another version makes her the stepmother of William Henry Bucke, who lived on the site in the 1830s. The hotel's spa and salon are named after her.

The rumor behind it

Bucke lived in an earlier house here, the Hermitage, under the name Henry Hall. After his death in 1836 it was learned, the hotel says, that he had embezzled theater funds in London. While the land was known as Otis Grove, the hotel's history says, "it was rumored that the house was haunted," and many believed Bucke had built an escape tunnel. No tunnel or record of Isabella has been found.

Dick O'Brien and the casino room

A second ghost is Dick O'Brien, said to be a caretaker who died in 1972; guests report seeing him on the main stairs or in his favorite chair, and he is blamed for laughter and pranks in the bar. Guests below the old casino room, where the roulette wheel stood, report hearing furniture moved at night. All these stories come from unnamed guests and staff. Some also say a worker died during construction.

Can you stay in Chambers in the Castle?

Yes, you can ask for it when you book.

The 11 named rooms in the 1889 castle. No single room is linked to a ghost; no elevator.

Ask when you book: nothing is guaranteed until the hotel agrees.

History of Belhurst Castle

Before the castle

The land was once the site of a Seneca village. Lawyer Joseph Fellows built the first modern house here, the Hermitage, though he never lived in it; William Henry Bucke lived there until his death in 1836. Harrison G. Otis bought the land in 1852.

Carrie Collins's castle

Carrie M. Young Harron bought the property in 1885, on the day she first saw it, and later married Captain Louis Dell Collins. Designed by Fuller & Wheeler and built of Medina sandstone, the castle took fifty men four years to build, from 1885 to 1889.

Speakeasy to hotel

Cornelius J. "Red" Dwyer bought Belhurst in 1932 and on April 18, 1933, opened it as a speakeasy and gambling casino; the casino ran until 1952. Robert and Nancy Golden bought it in 1975 and made the second and third floors and an outbuilding 12 guest rooms. Belhurst was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1987. Duane and Deb Reeder have owned it since 1992 and added the Vinifera Inn in 2004. Belhurst joined New York's Haunted History Trail in 2018.

Timeline

  1. 1836

    Bucke dies

  2. 1885

    Carrie Harron buys the land

  3. 1889

    The castle is finished

  4. April 18, 1933

    Speakeasy and casino open

  5. 1975

    Guest rooms open

  6. January 29, 1987

    National Register listing

  7. November 2, 1992

    The Reeders buy Belhurst

The evidence, claim by claim

What each story about Belhurst Castle rests on. A published account shows that someone reported an experience, not what caused it.

The land was the site of a Seneca village.

The hotel's own history.

[1]

Documented history

William Henry Bucke, living on the site as Henry Hall, died.

The hotel says he had embezzled theater funds in London.

[1], [2]

Documented history

Carrie M. Young Harron bought the property.

[1], [2]

Documented history

Belhurst Castle was built to designs by Fuller & Wheeler.

Some listings give 1888-92.

[3], [1], [2]

Documented history

Red Dwyer opened Belhurst as a speakeasy and gambling casino.

The casino ran until 1952.

[1], [2]

Documented history

Robert and Nancy Golden converted the castle's upper floors to guest rooms.

[1]

Documented history

Belhurst Castle was listed on the National Register of Historic Places.

[3]

Documented history

Duane and Deb Reeder became the owners.

[1], [2]

Documented history

Isabella, an opera singer, died when an escape tunnel to the lake collapsed on her.

No record of her or of a tunnel; versions disagree on who she was.

[4], [2], [5], [6]

Legend

The house on the site was rumored to be haunted and to have an escape tunnel.

Told by the hotel as rumor, from before the castle was built.

[1]

Legend

Guests see a woman in white on the front lawn at night.

Unnamed guests.

[4], [5], [6]

Unverified

Caretaker Dick O'Brien, who died in 1972, is seen on the stairs and blamed for pranks in the bar.

No named witness; his death date comes from tourism pages.

[4], [2], [5]

Unverified

A worker died during construction.

Told as "it's said"; no name or record.

[2], [5]

Unverified

Tips for staying at Belhurst Castle

  • Book a Chamber in the Castle for the old house; there are 11, each named, and no elevator. The Vinifera Inn rooms are modern.
  • Ask for the Bamboo Room, the only room still furnished with original pieces from 1889, by phone on (315) 781-0201.
  • It's a stop on New York's Haunted History Trail, and the Isabella Spa-Salon is open to non-guests.

Belhurst Castle: FAQs

Can you stay in Chambers in the Castle at Belhurst Castle?

Yes, you can ask for it when you book.

Which rooms at Belhurst Castle are haunted?

The most reported areas are: No single room; the stories are set on the lawn, stairs, bar and old casino room.

Is Belhurst Castle haunted?

It's known for the legend of Isabella, an opera singer said to walk the lawn in white, and for stories of a caretaker in the bar. No named witness has gone on record, and Isabella has no record behind her.

Who is Isabella at Belhurst Castle?

An opera singer said to have fled Europe with a lover and died when their escape tunnel to Seneca Lake collapsed. The legend belongs to the 1830s house on the site, and no record of her or the tunnel has been found.

Was Belhurst Castle a speakeasy?

Yes. Red Dwyer opened it as a speakeasy and gambling casino on April 18, 1933, and the casino ran until 1952.

Which room at Belhurst Castle is haunted?

No guest room is singled out. The stories are set on the lawn, the main stairs, the bar and the old casino room.

Guest experiences (0)

Share your experience →

No guest accounts yet. If you've stayed here, yours could be the first.

Share your experience

Sources

  1. History, Belhurst Castle The hotel's own history; mentions only a haunting rumor and a believed tunnel.Checked November 20, 2026
  2. Michael Kleen, Isabella's Spectral Form Chills Guests at Geneva's Belhurst Castle, Michael Kleen, October 30, 2019 Local history writer; links Isabella to Bucke and gives the casino dates.Checked November 20, 2026
  3. Belhurst Castle, Wikipedia National Register listing; its dates are inconsistent.Checked November 20, 2026
  4. Belhurst Castle, Haunted Rooms Commercial ghost guide; says no tunnel has been found.Checked November 20, 2026
  5. Belhurst Castle, Haunted History Trail of New York State Tourism listing; unnamed guests and staff.Checked November 20, 2026
  6. Belhurst Castle Joins Haunted History Trail of New York State, Finger Lakes Visitors Connection, September 7, 2018 Tourism release; retells the legend.Checked November 20, 2026

Page last reviewed November 20, 2026.

Brave enough to stay at Belhurst Castle?

Check room prices and availability for your dates.

Check prices & availabilityon Booking.com

More haunted hotels in New York

All haunted hotels in New York →
Beekman Arms and Delamater Inn
Unverified

Beekman Arms and Delamater Inn

Rhinebeck

A colonial inn on Rhinebeck's main crossroads, in business since 1766, where FDR ended his campaigns. Its ghost stories, of whispers in Rooms 21 and 22 and a dark figure in the wine cellar, come from unnamed staff and guests.

Check prices
The Adelphi Hotel
Unverified

The Adelphi Hotel

Saratoga Springs

The last of Saratoga Springs' 19th-century Broadway hotels, built in 1877 and reopened in 2017 after a long renovation. Boxer and casino founder John Morrissey died there in 1878; his ghost and a woman in a blue Victorian gown are local stories without named witnesses.

Check prices
Hotel Chelsea
Verified Haunt

Hotel Chelsea

New York

New York's 1884 home of writers, artists and musicians, reopened as a hotel in 2022. Residents tell of a weeping woman in the halls; her story has no record behind it.

Check prices